Caleb and Toby - Team Up

We love Caleb Rivers (Tyler Blackburn) and we love Toby Cavanaugh (Keegan Allen). So naturally, it should come as no surprise that we have we have entertained the idea of the two of them becoming BFFs and taking their girlfriends Hanna and Spencer on many double dates in Rosewood. And it seems as though the Pretty Little Liars writers heard our cries and fulfilled one half of our wish because in Season 4, Episode 7 Caleb and Toby are teaming up to investigate what really happened at the lodge the night of the fire. (You know, the one from which the Liars claimed to have been rescued by their dead best friend!)